In a detailed editorial in The Wall Street Journal, Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich explains the ways BlackRock and other money managers use client funds to push ESG principles, even without much input from their customers. He writes:
If asset managers have committed to push portfolio companies to attain net zero, how is the choice of approaching the “energy transition” left to the client? Even if BlackRock allows clients to vote their shares, BlackRock has pressured public companies long before any vote occurs. It appears that all clients buying BlackRock funds are forced to support ESG whether they like it or not. These actions raise more questions.
A diagram from a BlackRock report suggests ‘net zero’ is an implausible goal.PHOTO: BLACKROCK INVESTMENT INSTITUTE
The diagram nearby, taken from a BlackRock report, shows that governments are neither implementing nor pledging policies that would achieve net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. Would a prudent fiduciary bet everything on the green line?
Perhaps the trajectory for net zero will change. Perhaps a U.S. president with 40% approval ratings will build enduring majorities in Congress with a coalition that supports destroying the American energy sector and, in turn, perpetuating high energy prices, low economic growth, and inflation. Perhaps leftist Democrats will attain majorities sufficient to enact the Paris Agreement, impose a carbon tax, hold the presidency for decades, and subsidize green products until a “thousand Solyndras bloom.” Perhaps the world will ignore aggression by Russia and China to stay on track with emissions targets. Perhaps the U.S. will cheerfully shovel $8 trillion into China by 2030 for green investments, which is the amount BlackRock’s public documents state China needs to keep on track for net zero 2050.
Would a prudent fiduciary make company disclosures based on such unlikely events and negative investment returns its top priority? ESG simply isn’t a natural outgrowth of a focus on financial returns. And research reflects that some ESG funds have underperformed.
Brnovich continues later:
Maybe there is another explanation for asset managers’ actions. Asset managers make money by accumulating assets under management. Fellow members of BlackRock’s climate organizations include pension funds from states such as California, Connecticut, Illinois, Hawaii, New Jersey, New York, Oregon and Washington. Are asset managers making net-zero commitments to market themselves to these investors?
Consistent with this theory, BlackRock’s other ESG activities also are problematic. From 2020-21 BlackRock voted 1,554 times to impose gender quotas on company boards. In fact, imposing gender quotas was its top reason for opposing directors at companies in the Americas. What is the evidence that sex is the most important factor for director candidates, compared with other criteria like expertise related to pandemics, supply-chain disruption, or geopolitical conflict? Perhaps the best evidence of these improper ESG policies came in May, in Crest v. Padilla, when a California judge struck down California’s board-quota law.
My colleagues and I are committed to ending ESG practices that are rife with potential conflicts of interest and may be in violation of well-established laws. Amid a volatile market beset with inflation, properly managing Americans’ retirement funds should be a sufficient challenge for Wall Street. Asset managers’ social and legal purposes are the same: focus on financial returns.
Action Line: If your state’s attorney general is joining Brnovich in the fight against companies using your money to fund their political philosophy, count yourself lucky. If not, maybe it’s time to look for a better America. Start your search with my Super States. If you need to build an investment plan that eschews ESG funds and instead focuses on dividends and income, let’s talk. I’d love to help you. In the meantime, click here to sign up for my free monthly Survive & Thrive letter, and we can stay in touch.
E.J. Smith is Founder of YourSurvivalGuy.com, Managing Director at Richard C. Young & Co., Ltd., a Managing Editor of Richardcyoung.com, and Editor-in-Chief of Youngresearch.com. His focus at all times is on preparing clients and readers for “Times Like These.” E.J. graduated from Babson College in Wellesley, Massachusetts, with a B.S. in finance and investments. In 1995, E.J. began his investment career at Fidelity Investments in Boston before joining Richard C. Young & Co., Ltd. in 1998. E.J. has trained at Sig Sauer Academy in Epping, NH. His first drum set was a 5-piece Slingerland with Zildjians. He grew-up worshiping Neil Peart (RIP) of the band Rush, and loves the song Tom Sawyer—the name of his family’s boat, a Grady-White Canyon 306. He grew up in Mattapoisett, MA, an idyllic small town on the water near Cape Cod. He spends time in Newport, RI and Bartlett, NH—both as far away from Wall Street as one could mentally get. The Newport office is on a quiet, tree lined street not far from the harbor and the log cabin in Bartlett, NH, the “Live Free or Die” state, sits on the edge of the White Mountain National Forest. He enjoys spending time in Key West (RIP JB) and Paris.
Please get in touch with E.J. at ejsmith@yoursurvivalguy.com
To sign up for my free monthly Survive & Thrive letter, click here.
Latest posts by E.J. Smith - Your Survival Guy (see all)
Your Survival Guy visited my friend Marc Streisand this week, owner/proprietor of Marc Allen Fine Clothiers, Custom Suits, and Imported Sportswear, to pick up my handmade, bespoke cashmere sport coat. It’s such a beautiful piece, I can’t wait to put it on when we hit Paris for three weeks in October. Every time I leave […]
Well, Fred (gray) and Phantom (black) haven’t settled down yet, especially at nap time. What’s funny is how much Fred outweighs his little sister Phantom and how she’s ruling the roost. He’s definitely bigger and stronger, but she leads the way. Investment Concerns? Save Money. Get My Friday Email. It’s Free Read more […]
In The New York Sun, longtime Democrat Alan Dershowitz decries the party’s hijacking by the “hard left” and explains his reasons for leaving it after so many decades. He writes: I have been a loyal Democrat since the mid-1950s when I worked for local Democratic candidates at Brooklyn. Since 1960 I have voted for every […]
Well, that was an interesting debate, wasn’t it? Not exactly a seminar on how to win friends and influence people. When I talk with you, you tell me it didn’t sway you one bit. And you feel the same way about the undecided voters—they weren’t compelled either way. When I think of Dale Carnegie’s classic […]
Investors are getting nervous about the stock market and are making moves to more traditionally defensive sectors of the market. Remember to stay diversified because it’s not what you invest in but how you invest that stirs the drink. Hardika Singh reports in The Wall Street Journal: Investors are playing defense ahead of the Federal […]
Video game workers. Now, that’s an oxymoron if I’ve ever heard one. What’s noteworthy is the continued softening of sales post-pandemic. I like Microsoft’s positioning to reduce its video game workforce in the face of what might be a slowdown in demand. Sarah E. Needleman reports for The Wall Street Journal: Microsoft is laying off […]
We knew going in that former President Donald Trump would not get a fair shake from ABC, but it felt like we were watching a trial from The Hunger Games without the costumes. Vice President Kamala Harris was treated like the incumbent and heir to the throne by the moderators. The primetime show was borderline […]
Americans miss the days when their wages were rising in real (inflation-adjusted) terms powered by the Trump tax cuts. For the last three years, they’ve been burdened by higher spending from the Biden-Harris administration, with the outcome being more Americans on the government dole for things like healthcare, rather than being able to afford it […]
America’s sunbelt is attracting businesses eager to invest in the usually low-tax, low-regulatory states. Will Parker reports for The Wall Street Journal: The U.S. is experiencing a manufacturing revival. More property investors are eager to capitalize on it. American and overseas companies have committed nearly half a trillion dollars to build new factories for electric […]
When you invest in a passive index, is it passive? The idea behind “passive” is that the stock market is “efficient,” and that there are no real values to be had because of the wisdom of crowds. Tell that to Warren Buffett, who’s made a decent living for decades on investing against the ignorance and […]
In The Wall Street Journal, Tom Dotan discusses the revitalization of Oracle, which “missed the tech industry’s move to cloud computing last decade and ended up an also-ran.” Dotan explains that the AI boom has given Oracle another shot, writing: The 47-year-old company that made its name on relational database software has emerged as an […]
You know them as Your Survival Guy’s Escape States. These are states like California, Illinois, and New York, where income earners are treated like piggy banks to be withdrawn from in order to fund politicians’ ideological spending ideas. Residents aren’t treated like customers to be served by government, they’re expected to serve government through punitive […]
A word on stock market prices and their nephew past performance. When investors pile into the S&P 500 the way so many do—automatically with their 401(k) contributions—there’s a tremendous amount of money riding on the same stuff. Investors, knowingly or unknowingly, get piled into the same boat, hoping and praying to get to their retirement […]
Remember, it’s not what you invest in but how you invest that matters most. With the mini pullback in stocks, look at how well-balanced portfolios have done. In The Wall Street Journal, Jon Sindreau explains that the last few months have shown (once again) the value of a balanced portfolio of stocks and bonds. He […]
The stock market has minted millionaires this year, reports Gunjan Banjerji in The Wall Street Journal. That’s not bad, but Americans, as Banerji explains, “have rarely been this giddy about the stock market.” Banerji writes: U.S. households’ stock allocations have steadily inched up this year, according to JPMorgan estimates, and recently accounted for around 42% […]
