California’s Wealth Tax and the French Connection

By Vitalii Vodolazskyi @ Shutterstock.com

You know that the French economy is in trouble, possibly a debt trap. That’s one reason it’s difficult to understand the eagerness of California politicians and activists who want to implement a wealth tax championed by famed French economists like Gabriel Zucman, Thomas Piketty, and Emmanuel Saez. Zucman, a professor at the Paris School of Economics, spends his summers as a research professor at UC Berkeley and is the ringleader of the effort to tax the state’s billionaires. He has suggested similar taxes for France, and has been wholeheartedly endorsed by the country’s socialists.

The problem with Zucman’s support for California’s wealth tax is that he may not understand that, unlike France, there are plenty of individual states that welcome the successful with open arms. The Editorial Board of The Wall Street Journal notes that recent research by the Hoover Institute suggests a far smaller bounty will be appropriated by the wealth tax than Zucman & Co. suggest. They write:

If nothing else, the debate over the California wealth tax on the Nov. 3 ballot is exposing the dishonesty of the case for it. Consider the intellectual gyrations of Gabriel Zucman, the French economist now at Berkeley and a leading Prop. 40 proponent.

Monsieur Zucman is frantically, if fruitlessly, trying to discredit the Hoover Institution paper we told you about last week. Prop. 40 supporters say the supposedly one-time 5% tax on residents with more than $1 billion in net worth would raise $100 billion in revenue. But that estimate ignores that many billionaires will leave the state.

Hoover economists Benjamin Jaros and Joshua Rauh estimate that the wealth tax would raise only $30 billion after taking into account that courts are likely to block some of its provisions and billionaires will leave the state. They also estimate that the decline in annual income-tax payments over time will exceed this wealth tax revenue by $38.9 billion.

The Editors hit home by concluding:

Left-wing French economists are the leading intellectual architects of France’s—and Europe’s—current fiscal and political uproar. You almost have to wonder if they are so determined for the U.S. to make the same mistakes because America’s relative success is an embarrassing rebuke to their ideas.

Action Line: Does America really want to follow these French economists down the rabbit hole of no growth and rising debt? I say this as someone who thinks highly of France and has been there many times, but judging by the experience of France and the EU as a whole, no, thank you. Click here to subscribe to my free monthly Survive & Thrive letter.