
You know that Californians defeated the proposed Prop 40 Wealth Tax on the ballot this year. At the Cato Institute, Adam Michel explains that the rich have often found ways around such wealth taxes. He writes:
The wealthy leave countries and states to avoid wealth taxes, but they also exploit tax exemptions. The French discounted taxes on forestry and vineyards, so tax advisers marketed timber and vineyards as tax shelters. Lawmakers also carved out an exemption for art, which encouraged taxpayers to purchase expensive paintings to protect their assets from the levy.
In an attempt to tax the most extravagant forms of wealth, France levied a yacht tax in 2018, projecting it would raise 10 million euros ($11.8 million) per year. By 2025, only five large yachts remained eligible for the tax in France, and the tax collected just 60,000 euros in 2024 ($64,900) — less than 1 percent of the estimate. Tax yachts, and they will literally sail away.
Despite the poor performance history of wealth taxes, Michel notes that wealth tax supporters in California are prepared to try again in 2028.
Despite regular reminders that wealth taxes are generally unpopular, such measures always seem in vogue. California wealth-tax advocates are already plotting a 2028 do-over, and with large majorities in Congress after January, Democrats are likely to push for similar proposals federally. Economists like me spend much of our time explaining how wealth taxes hurt employers, drive out investment and raise little revenue. But the absurd things people do to avoid them can be even more revealing.
Are Wealth Taxes Constitutional?
At the Tax Foundation, Jared Walczak suggests that Prop 40-style wealth taxes are “vulnerable to numerous constitutional challenges, any of which could invalidate the tax in whole or in part.” He writes:
If California adopts a wealth tax, the only undisputed winners will be the lawyers. The California Billionaire Tax Act (CBTA), appearing on the November 3, 2026, ballot as Proposition 40, is vulnerable to a range of legal challenges on numerous grounds and on multiple levels: as-applied challenges to the tax imposed on specific individuals; challenges to the validity of specific provisions as written, like the snapshot residency and valuation dates; and challenges to the constitutionality of the tax as a whole.
A prior paper examined how litigation over the CBTA’s residency and valuation provisions could require judicial reformation, eliminating some or all wealth tax liability for billionaires who leave the state in 2026—if the tax could survive such a challenge at all.[1] This paper explores the more fundamental question of whether the proposed wealth tax passes constitutional muster.
The measure’s drafters fully anticipated that their proposal would draw intense legal scrutiny and recognized that it would raise serious constitutional questions. They embedded a set of preemptive legal defenses into the tax’s design, attempting to insulate it from these challenges. But not all potential constitutional infirmities can be overcome by legal cunning, and the measure’s defensive provisions are an acknowledgment of a wealth tax’s fundamental legal vulnerabilities.
If courts invalidate the tax, California will have the worst of all worlds: a threat that drives away some of the state’s wealthiest taxpayers and spooks the next wave of startup founders, costly litigation that could drag on for years, and not a single dollar in new revenue. This is not a minor concern. The tax is legally dubious as well as economically damaging.
Action Line: Wealth taxes are legally unsound and have shown to be ineffective. Voters should reject wealth taxes again in 2028 and beyond. Click here to subscribe to my free monthly Survive & Thrive letter.



